Birmingham City are poised to seal the signing of AZ Alkmaar striker Moussa Dembele in a deal worth in the region of £5million.
The 23-year-old Belgium international has spent the last four years with the Dutch outfit, but is expected to move on, with the Blues facing competition from a number of other clubs for Dembele’s signature.
The player himself told the Birmingham Mail:“The Premier League is the strongest in the world. I know I can be successful in a big league.
“Birmingham City is the most concrete option, but other clubs have also shown an interest.
“I have waited for more opportunities and now I have to look at the pros and the cons. I would like to decide by next week, but in my head I have a preference.”
The Blues have so far drafted in just two players this summer, with goalkeeper Ben Foster arriving from Manchester United and striker Nikola Zigic joining from Valencia.
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
Subscribe to Football FanCast News Headlines by Email
As football fans, we see what we want to see. We defend our own, and attack others. Our club is the best, and that’s that. We can attack our own of course, that’s our prerogative, but outside criticism is seen as bias and prejudice.
Ben Goldacre, a well-known campaigner against lies told about science in the media, once commented in a column on the following experiment:
“What do people do when confronted with scientific evidence that challenges their pre-existing view? Often they will try to ignore it, intimidate it, buy it off, sue it for libel or reason it away.
The classic paper on the last of those strategies is from Lord, Ross and Lepper in 1979: they took two groups of people, one in favour of the death penalty, the other against it, and then presented each with a piece of scientific evidence that supported their pre-existing view, and a piece that challenged it; murder rates went up or down, for example, after the abolition of capital punishment in a state.
The results were as you might imagine. Each group found extensive methodological holes in the evidence they disagreed with, but ignored the very same holes in the evidence that reinforced their views.”
I mention the above as a somewhat clumsy analogy about football fans. As you’re probably aware, we’re blinkered hypocrites, the lot of us. Or maybe you weren’t.
But you probably were.
And so this is how it works. Craig Bellamy plays for your team and thus he is brilliant, such dedication, passionate, all that charity work in Sierra Leone (amazing work, for sure), puts 110% in, sued so many papers for lies told against him (14 actions in one year in fact), says it as it is and so on. Then he leaves, signs for Spurs, and slags off City, and he’s a prize a***hole, falls out with every club he goes to, gobs**te, always knew he was trouble, his knee’s gone, horrible tattoos.
I’m just about to enter the second camp.
Robinho? All these stories about him wanting to leave are rubbish, of course he’s not lazy, he scored 15 goals, a good return, took time for him to settle, niggling injuries, flying round world with Brazil took it out of him etc. Why do the media have to stir up trouble all the time? On news that he refuses to return to Manchester? What a ****. Lazy, pompous, arrogant, piece of ****. £200,000 a week and he couldn’t be arsed training most days, he’s treated us all like fools, good riddance, falls out with every club he goes to, only puts in effort for Brazil, etc etc. £300,000 a week and it’s too cold for him, boo hoo, get the violins out, my heart bleeds.
And so the re-writing of history continued when Milner looked poised to sign for City. Suddenly on website letter pages, Villa fans comment on how he was average, a one-season wonder, overrated etc. Young is the real talent at Villa Park. Last season he was the messiah, now he’s just a very naughty boy. And as for O’ Neill? Rubbish. Long ball merchant, boring to watch, terrible in the transfer market, wouldn’t make changes, set in his ways.
(Of course City have paid too much for Milner, but leaving that aside, he’s a very good player, with commitment, dedication, and a desire to succeed. Villa will miss him, whatever their fans say, but the money provides an opportunity to replace him and perhaps acquire another couple of bargains as well. Everyone wins, I guess.)
As I write, City are linked with Balotelli (in fact, he’s just signed!), but United were rumoured to be after him too. So what do I think of him? Well, put it like this. If he had signed for United, he’s a young hothead with an attitude problem, an immature child who is seriously overpriced. Now he has signed for us, he is misunderstood, had to put up with racial abuse, got huge potential and Mancini will get the best out of him.
I hope that makes my feelings clear.
And then there are the contentious match issues. Battle lines are drawn up, and the same event, viewable form multiple camera angles and at 4 different speeds, brings out totally different opinions on who was to blame and what should be done. Would we have it any other way?
Take Ben Thatcher’s elbow on Mendes a good few years ago. If Mendes had got up, I argued to anyone who would listen (and a few who wouldn’t), there would have been no media furore. I studied the replays trying to find some evidence, any evidence that maybe it wasn’t as bad as it looked. It was. I saw De Jong’s karate kick on Alonso in the World Cup final and argued, “well surely he would not deliberately try and maim someone?! Nah, it was just clumsy and mistimed…”
I still think this, even though I imagine it makes me look like a fool. Now if a United player had made that tackle…..
But for me, the best example of the blinker-wearing approach of football fans is a contentious penalty decision. Here we have the perfect example of a football fan seeing what they want to see. I once saw Sun Jihai win a penalty against Everton with an appalling dive that took in a triple salko, pirouette, a wave to the crowd, a pretend knee injury and he still had time to look appealingly at the referee. We could all see it was a dive. But in my mind, I tried to reason he was expecting a bad tackle so was merely jumping out the way and besides, thirteen years previously Everton had got a really dodgy decision against us, so it all evened up really.
Did Stephen Hunt mean to hurt Cech? Did Taylor mean to cripple Eduardo? Was that elbow deliberate, or just used for leverage? Did he go down easily there, or was he clipped? All the answers depend on which team you support. You scour the replays, and you home in on the clip that best fits the opinion you want to have.
So according to your particular allegiance, two possible interpretations emerge from a crunching, injury-causing tackle/foul:
Continued on Page TWO
Scenario a: defend tackle, slam the outrage being shown over incident, use other examples to show how similar incidents didn’t get such coverage. Write angry letter to football365.com. Sulk for 2 days.
Scenario b: slam tackle, perhaps suggest the player has got form for this, slam the lack of outrage in the media over this horrendous foul, use examples of your team getting slated for much lesser incidents. Write angry letter to football365.com. Sulk for 2 days.
Of course, this hypocrisy is essentially pointless – the need to defend our corner comes from the tribal nature of football, but why would I need to defend Ben Thatcher? I am not responsible for anything players do – it is out of my hands, as, like 99% of football fans, I am powerless to change their behaviour, or more importantly, my club’s fortunes. A passionate crowd can help a home team, a dedicated supporters group can change the course of a club, but on the whole we make no difference. We follow blindly through whatever crops up.
And so I shouldn’t really feel the need to defend City’s spending policy, but in the last blog I did just that. At the end of the day, I didn’t have any say in the takeover, and I don’t have any say in how they act. And let’s face it, there’s not a group of supporters in the world who would start protesting because their owners were spending TOO MUCH money. Maybe an Amish club, but I imagine their Fit & Proper Persons Test is pretty damn strict.
You will often hear people say things like “club X have always played attractive football” or “their supporters demand attacking football” and the like, but I have my doubts at how many managers have changed their own tactics because of some supposed historical demand from the fans. Maybe it has influenced the odd managerial appointment though. So as a mass, supporters can influence, but individually few do, and thus few are accountable for what their clubs do.
This leads me onto another point. We all have at least a hint of bias as fans, but that raises the question of whether journalists are too. Presumably all football journalists support a particular team. I’ve rarely met a fan of football who had no club allegiance, and those few I have met I have subconsciously treated with suspicion (like people who don’t own a television). What is football without glory, without rivalry, without defending your corner and attacking someone else’s, the highs and the oh-so-many lows?
Personally if I was a journalist writing about the Premier League, I would find it difficult to write impartially on City, and by association, United also. So I did a little experiment, using webchats, twitter, emails and the like. I asked every football journalist I could find the following question:
“Do you think it is possible for sports journalists to write fairly and impartially on football when they support a particular (high profile) team? My experiences suggest not…..”
These were the replies, in full. I won’t name names, but they all write for national papers, with one exception.
Continued on Page THREE
“Good question Howard. As football fans we all have certain teams in our heart. I don’t think my lifelong allegiance affects my objectivity when reporting on that team or any rival teams. You may beg to differ….
“I’m not sure whether Crystal Palace counts as a high-profile team, but one of the most important tools for a modern newspaper reporter is the ability to write with conviction.
“I don’t expect anyone to agree with my opinions, but my aim is to write with integrity, as well as providing a well-reasoned and balanced argument based on my knowledge of a subject.
“When I have covered Palace in the past, a number of managers criticised me for being too critical of the club and I wouldn’t disagree.
Being professional is one thing, trying to disassociate myself from the team I have followed throughout my life is entirely different. I’m professional in the day job.”
*
“Quite why so many fans are obsessed with what teams journos support is beyond me!”
*
“It does not matter which team individual writers support. This is like saying you must be pro-police to cover crime. What matters is content and getting the balance right between city and united coverage.”
*
“Depends Howard. If I’m writing a news piece or a match report, then it has to be objective. If it’s a piece that clearly marks me as a Liverpool fan, then it does what it says on the tin. Some hide their allegiance, I don’t. Anyway, I’ve been accused of all kinds – being an Everton fan or Man United. Most of my reporters are passionate fans of clubs. Hang on, all of them. We argue and abuse each other but are professional enough that you’d never know from their writing.
“I support Cambridge United so impartiality has never been a problem. Sometimes supporters can be the harshest judges so I don’t think that’s a specific problem. A bigger issue is probably trying to think and write independently when you are dealing with contacts, individuals you like.
“Although every football reporter goes into journalism with some kind of allegiance, very few stick with it as they progress. From my point of view, the old rivalries disappear when you get to know people and players from other clubs. Similarly, you can find people who work for the club you ‘supported’ difficult to deal with, so that also helps get rid of loyalties.
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
“A few guys certainly get too wrapped up in England team results, but the vast majority of reporters I know do not allow any allegiances to colour their judgement. At the top end of the profession, you can’t get away with club bias. I know many fans think we are all Utd / City / Arsenal / Chelsea fans. I’ve been accused of being all four, so that sums it up!”
*
“I am a journalist who happens to cover football. So the ethics of informing people of the truth, being accurate, objective, fair, impartial and proving debate, must hold true. Supporting a team doesn’t give a journalist a right to express opinions, unsupported by facts or a sound basis. It therefore helps if a sports reporter has been first trained as a news reporter. There is no need for a journalist to make their allegiance to a team known to the public. It serves no benefit to them, the reader or the club. It can only invite criticism from fans. The loss of impartiality affects the credibility of the journalist and that of the media outlet.”
“It is an interesting question, and I am not sure that it is possible for any journalist to write completely impartially about a match in a division in which their team competes. Obviously you try to comment as fairly as possible, but journalists, much like every other football fan, will have their prejudices and they will inevitably colour their writing. It just depends on the writer as to how much they can mask the level of their impartiality. Some clearly find it tougher than others!”
*
“Yes of course it’s possible. It’s part of the journalistic DNA. But not a problem I face because I support Dundee!”
*
So there you have it. Most journalists asked think that professionalism in their job overrides any personal allegiances they may have. I can’t say I am convinced. The journalists that replied have pretty good reputations in my opinion, and I believe them. I’m not convinced by journalists as a whole though because, like you all I would wager, I think a particular newspaper has it in for my team (it’s the Mirror by the way), and even more so, I think individual journalists do too. Above all, I have seen certain journalists, usually from the redtops, spend the last few weeks intent on carrying out a hatchet job on our national football manager with reporting that bore no resemblance to the standards of objectivity and impartiality mentioned in the email replies above. Much of the coverage has been nothing short of a disgrace, and an abomination. And the one journalist that replied saying bias does come into it works for a redtop. Make of that what you will.
As I have mentioned, for years now I have seen some of them repeatedly pen articles slagging off my club at every opportunity possible, which if we had been on a blazing trail of tyranny would be fair enough – but let’s face it, we haven’t done enough to be considered the spawn of Satan just yet.
Three uncapped players have been named in Fabio Capello's 23-man England squad for the friendly international against Hungary at Wembley on Wednesday.
Arsenal duo Jack Wilshere and Kieran Gibbs are both included, as is Fulham striker Bobby Zamora.
Among those to be left out are West Ham goalkeeper Robert Green and fellow custodian David James, now with Bristol City, with both Ben Foster and Paul Robinson back in the fold.
Everton defender Phil Jagielka is given an opportunity to impress, as are Bolton centre-half Gary Cahill, Manchester City winger Adam Johnson, Ashley Young of Aston Villa and Sunderland striker Darren Bent.
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
Squad: Foster (Birmingham), Hart (Manchester City), Robinson (Blackburn); Brown (Manchester United), Cahill (Bolton), A Cole (Chelsea), Dawson (Tottenham), Gibbs (Arsenal), Jagielka (Everton), G Johnson (Liverpool), Terry (Chelsea); Barry (Manchester City), Gerrard (Liverpool), A Johnson (Manchester City), Lampard (Chelsea), Milner (Aston Villa), Young (Aston Villa), Walcott (Arsenal), Wilshere (Arsenal); Bent (Sunderland), C Cole (West Ham), Rooney (Manchester United), Zamora (Fulham).Subscribe to Football FanCast News Headlines by Email
Tottenham have been dealt a second serious injury blow in a matter of days after it was confirmed that the ankle ligament injury Jermain Defoe picked up during England's 3-1 win in Switzerland on Tuesday will keep him sidelined for up to six weeks.
Defoe, who scored a hat-trick in last week's 4-0 Euro 2012 qualfying victory against Bulgaria, had to be stretchered off the pitch in Basel although it was initially thought the problem was not serious.
However, after undergoing scans in London, the former West Ham United and Portsmouth star has been told he will not be back in action until late October.
Last week manager Harry Redknapp learned that the knee and ankle injuries Michael Dawson sustained against Bulgaria at Wembley would keep the defender sidelined for two months.
Redknapp has Peter Crouch, Roman Pavlyuchenko, Robbie Keane and Giovani dos Santos in his squad to replace Defoe but will be aware that only Gareth Bale has found the net in Spurs' first three Premier League matches of the campaign.
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
Defoe will miss the Champions League games against Werder Bremen and Inter Milan, the Premier League fixtures against West Ham United and Aston Villa as well as the Carling Cup third-round tie with Arsenal.Subscribe to Football FanCast News Headlines by Email
A mixed week at Arsenal as an appalling showing last week at the Emirates was followed up by an impressive Champions League victory. Arsene Wenger needs to find some consistency and quick, if he wants to challenge for the title this season.
This week at FFC we have seen a mixed bag of blogs that include…£12m outlay money well spent; Wenger set to solve goalkeeping crisis and do Arsenal’s problems lie a lot deeper than Manuel Almunia.
Plus we have taken a look at the best Arsenal stories on the Web this week.
The Premiership’s ‘Most Hated’ XI of all time?
£12m outlay will prove money well spent for Arsenal
Do Arsenal’s problems actually run a lot deeper?
Should United and Arsenal force City’s hand with January bid?
Wenger set to FINALLY solve goalkeeping debacle?
Arsene Wenger’s BOLD claims not far from the truth
London Calling – 10 Things I noticed from Champions League Tuesday
Time Arsene Wenger gave starlet his chance at the Emirates
Is it simply win or bust for Arsenal?
The real Samir Nasri finally stands up
Is Arsene Wenger changing his ways?
‘Shuda, Wuda, Cuda’ – Top FIVE transfers deals that got away
*
Best of Web
*
Howlmunia puts £56million profit into perspective. Ratings and match report – Le Grove
Jack set for a spell on the bench? Brady and Coyle speak out…. – Highbury House
Clichy Gets Ugly Whilst Wenger Gets Physical – A Cultured Left Foot
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
A cushy three points on Sunday then? – Online Gooner
Lavishly-talented Wilshere central to Arsenal’s hopes – Daily Telegraph
Credit where credit is due but bad memories fail to convince! Yet! – Highbury House
*
Click on the image below to see the Top 10 Premier WAGs!
Christian Purslow has stepped down from his temporary position as Liverpool's managing director following last week's successful £300million sale of the club to New England Sports Ventures (NESV).
However, Purslow will remain at Anfield as a non-executive director and will also act as a special adviser to the new owners.
NESV chairman Tom Werner said of the news: "We are delighted Christian has accepted our offer to help us and the club, given his great experience and love for Liverpool FC. We will now begin a global search process for a chief executive officer."
Purslow added:"I came to Liverpool to lead the club through a sale process to get the best overall deal including, vitally, the removal of the debt. I am immensely proud of what we have all achieved.
"I now look forward to assisting the owners in any way I can at this exciting time as they drive the club forward to a bright future."
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
Purslow took up the post in the summer of 2009 when he replaced Rick Parry.Subscribe to Football FanCast News Headlines by Email
Liverpool goalkeeper Jose Reina has confirmed his commitment to the club, following recent rumours linking him with a move away from Anfield.
The 28-year-old Spain international insists that he remains fully committed to a long-term future with the Reds, having moved to England from Villarreal in the summer of 2005.
Reina told the club's official website:"I have seen a newspaper has made this suggestion. It is completely untrue.
"I have not told the manager that I wish to leave in January or at any other time. It is important our fans know this.
"I have a long-term contract at Liverpool and I am fully committed to the club.
"Our new owner met me and some of the other players last week and I was very happy with what he told me.
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
"The entire squad and staff are working very hard to get us back competing at the top of the table. We will not be distracted by inaccurate media speculation."Subscribe to Football FanCast News Headlines by Email
Tottenham firmly announced themselves on the European stage this week, with a comfortable 3-1 defeat of holders Inter Milan. After their impressive by ultimately futile, second half display at the San Siro two weeks ago, this performance had Tottenham legends of the past comparing the victory to some of the club’s most memorable nights.
During a busy week for Spurs, there was also enough time for a controversial late goal conceded last week, and a very interesting game of cat and mouse between Harry Redknapp and the Premier League.
Wednesday’s result has sent the blogging networks into overdrive. There are entries on Gareth Bale’s rise from statistical burden to world beater, Peter Crouch’s none too impressive strike rate since his move from Portsmouth and potential transfer targets for Spurs during January’s window.
As always we also have the best of the web.
Featured articles of the week
*
The Premier League’s new comic strip # 2
Walcott and Bale finally fulfilling the hype
Why Peter Crouch needs to take a back seat
Four transfer targets for Tottenham to ponder
Another FIVE things we learnt from Tottenham’s demolition
How Inter star failed his transfer audition at White Hart Lane
Give technology an inch in football, then eventually it will take a mile
One DEAL that Daniel Levy has to get right
There’s simply no better inspiration for Gareth Bale to follow
Spurs, Liverpool, United…whose need for Real Madrid swoop is greater?
WAG Weekly: Bale scores a beauty…well sort off!
*
Click here to see the Best TOTTENHAM BLOGS around the Web this week
Best of the Web
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
Do you know your history? – Dear Mr Levy
Inter for supper: Trotters for lunch – Spurs Musings with JimmyG2
Bale, Taxis and Two Fiddy’s Up – Who Framed Ruel Fox?
Sign This Petition And Help Get Him Sacked – Harry Hotspur
Another fine mess Mr Clattenburg- Spurs Musings with JimmyG2
Aston Villa boss Gerard Houllier was disappointed with his young team's display in the 2-0 defeat at Blackburn Rovers that left them in the bottom half of the table.
Morten Gamst Pedersen netted in each half to extend Villa's dismal away record and Houllier had few complaints with the final result at Ewood Park.
He admitted after the loss:"I don't think we gave a fair account of ourselves. We had a couple of chances in the first half and, when you are away from home, you need to take those chances, otherwise you can be punished.
"We then conceded a goal probably at the worst moment in the game, in (first-half) added time.
"It puts you in a different position because you know they are then going to play deeper and more defensive, and deny us space.
"The second goal was just a tactical mistake, so the difference between the two teams was a free-kick by Pedersen and a corner.
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
"We showed better initiative and passing afterwards and, had we scored, maybe it would have changed the morale of the team – but of course we didn't."Subscribe to Football FanCast News Headlines by Email
Avram Grant will have be pleased with the point at Upton Park this evening.
The West Ham boss has been under immense pressure of late; however the league table is starting to open up and with West Ham only two points away from moving out of the drop zone, there appears to be some light at the end of the tunnel. It was a hard fought point in the end and the Hammers defence held firm right until the end.
So how do West Ham fans feel about tonight’s point, and what are the five things we have learnt from the Hammers tonight?
FootballFanCast General: Subscribe and never miss what matters Stay ahead in the world of football analysis, commentary, and fan insights with FootballFancast.
By subscribing, you agree to receive newsletter and marketing emails, and accept Valnet’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe anytime.
[divider]
Holy Crap – it’s live fantasy football! Become part of Birmingham v Man United and play Picklive for FREE Watch and bet live – spices up any game!